🧐 Gerrard vs. Ancelotti: Who Should Be the Next Rangers Manager?

🏟️ A Big Decision for Rangers: Gerrard or Ancelotti?

With the managerial position wide open, two big names have emerged in the discussion of who will be Rangers next manager: Steven Gerrard and Davide Ancelotti. One is a returning hero. The other is a rising star with elite pedigree.

Let’s break down the pros and cons of each to help decide who might be the best fit to lead the team back to glory.

---

👑 Steven Gerrard: The Return of a Rangers Legend?

If Rangers are looking for a familiar face to take the reins, Steven Gerrard stands out as a strong contender for the Rangers next manager. The Liverpool legend led the club to its historic 55th league title, restoring pride and stability at Ibrox after years of rebuilding. Gerrard already understands the pressures and expectations of managing Rangers, both on and off the pitch. While his time in the English Premier League was mixed, his proven ability to lead in the Scottish Premiership could make him the safe and emotionally powerful choice for the job.

✅ Pros:

• Knows the club inside and out
  Gerrard’s previous spell at Ibrox brought home the club’s historic 55th league title.
• Respected by players and fans
  He commands respect, not just as a football legend, but as a proven leader.
• Understands Scottish football
  Having battled with Celtic, he knows the intensity of the league and the expectations at Rangers.

❌ Cons:

• Mixed success since leaving Rangers
  His time at Aston Villa was underwhelming, raising questions about progress since Ibrox.
• Tactical predictability
  Critics argue his system can lack flexibility when under pressure.

---

🧠 Davide Ancelotti: A Modern Manager in the Making?

For those wanting a bold new direction, Davide Ancelotti is an intriguing candidate for the Rangers next manager. The son of legendary coach Carlo Ancelotti, Davide has quietly built a reputation as one of Europe’s brightest young minds, serving as assistant at Real Madrid, Everton, and Bayern Munich. While he lacks first-team managerial experience, his tactical education at the highest level and modern coaching style could offer Rangers a fresh, forward-thinking approach. Appointing Ancelotti would be a calculated risk—but one that could transform the club’s identity and long-term vision.

✅ Pros:

• Elite footballing education
  As Carlo Ancelotti’s right-hand man, he’s been part of Champions League-winning teams at Real Madrid.
• Modern tactical approach
  He’s known for a data-driven, flexible, and progressive style of coaching.
• Fresh perspective
  Could offer something new and exciting that Rangers haven’t had before.

❌ Cons:

• No head coach experience
  Davide has never led a team on his own—this would be a huge first step.
• No Scottish football background
  The SPFL is a unique challenge, and there’s no guarantee he’d adapt quickly.

---

🗣️ What Are the Experts Saying?

The debate isn’t just happening among fans—pundits and former players have strong views too.

Kris Boyd, former Rangers striker, has spoken in favor of Gerrard’s return:

“Steven brought a winning mentality back to Ibrox. He knows what it means to manage Rangers. He’s the logical choice if the club wants to restore identity and discipline.”

Ally McCoist, club legend and commentator, expressed curiosity about Ancelotti:

“Davide’s credentials are impressive. He’s worked at the top of the game under one of the best in the business. It would be a bold move—but maybe bold is what Rangers need right now.”

Meanwhile, Pat Nevin, a respected Scottish football pundit, weighed in:

“Ancelotti might not have been a manager in name, but he’s been learning at the very highest level. That kind of experience, even as an assistant, counts for more than people realise.”

These differing takes from experienced voices show how finely balanced the decision really is—and how either option brings something compelling to the table.

---

🔍 Final Verdict: Who Should It Be?

There’s no perfect choice. Gerrard brings familiarity and passion. Ancelotti brings innovation and potential. It comes down to this:

• If Rangers want a safe, emotionally driven return, Gerrard is the guy.
• If they want to gamble on something bold and modern, Ancelotti could be the future.

Whichever direction the board takes, fans should brace for a defining chapter in the club’s future.